Q. First let me say that my wife and I thoroughly enjoy your magazine and I especially like the "Sunken Gardens" column. I hope you will be able to help me. I have a 50-gallon freshwater tank with live plants and use 110 watts of light. Everything seems fine except the water temperature is very high now, at 84 degrees Fahrenheit.
Could you recommend something that would help? I am concerned with the long-term health of both the fish and plants in this environment. Also note that the tank receives no direct sunlight and the hood that I constructed is open at the back to allow fresh air access. The lights are fluorescent and are suspended approximately 6 inches above the water line. I cannot raise them higher.
Finally, any advice on keeping stem plants anchored in the gravel? I only have tetras and corys.
A. Thank you very much for the kind words! I am surprised to hear that 110 watts of fluorescent light is heating up your tank, particularly where it is quite a distance above the water level. Here in the Northeast I run my 55-gallon tank with 160 watts and my 70-gallon tank with 240 watts — in both tanks I must use heaters for the better part of the year. Here are some things to check to see where the heat buildup is coming from, and a few ideas on how to alleviate the problem.
While 84 degrees Fahrenheit might be higher than ideal for many aquarium fish and plants, it is not unmanageably high. In fact, aquarists who keep planted discus tanks often maintain their tanks at this temperature on purpose. Still, I can understand your desire to keep the tank a little cooler.
If your room temperature is substantially higher than average (usually 68 to 72 degrees) you won't need much extra heat from the lights to send the temperature of the tank water up. This can affect even those who live in cooler areas of the country during summer heat waves. As a temporary expedient, the cover can be cracked open and air from a fan blown across the water surface to facilitate evaporative cooling. Keeping windows open and moving air through the entire house will also keep heat from building up around the tank.
In a worst-case scenario, if temperatures are remaining above 90 degrees in the tank for extended periods, cut the photoperiod down and shift it into the evening hours when the house is likely to be cooler. At these temperatures, it is probably a good idea to run an airstone in the tank when the lights aren't on to make sure the oxygen levels stay high enough not to stress your fish.
If the room isn't too warm, the heat is probably coming from some equipment associated with the tank. If you have a large filter or other electrical equipment in a closed cabinet under the tank, these can add to heat build up. Finally, as you have mentioned, the lights can put off quite a bit of heat.
If the lights are mounted inside a wooden canopy, the wood will act as a very good insulator, keeping the heat in. You noted that the back of the canopy is open, but even with this the heat may build up in the enclosed area. Small fans called "muffin fans" can be purchased from electronic supply stores and installed inside the hood to move the warm air out. Electronic ballasts produce less heat than cheaper "tar" ballasts, and thus are a better alternative. You might also consider mounting the ballast(s) in a remote location to completely remove this heat source.
One further thought occurs to me — the thermometer you are using. Are you sure it's reasonably accurate? If it is mounted close to the top of the tank, it might not be giving an accurate representation of the temperature of the entire tank. This is particularly true if your tank does not have a reasonable amount of water movement. Many filtration systems both remove and return water close to the surface of the tank. If there is no supplemental method of water movement, you can end up with a situation in which the warmer upper water layer is not mixing with the cooler bottom water layer. If this is a problem, it is easily alleviated by the use of one or more small powerheads dropped deep enough in the tank that they create flow just above the surface of the substrate.
While I would look for ways to reduce the temperature in a tank, in the meantime you should rest easy. Except for a few cool water species, most commercially available tropical fish and plants are very adaptable and will do fine even in the low 80s. Most can tolerate even higher temperatures for short periods if other conditions in the tank are good.
As far as anchoring stem plants is concerned, unless you are using gravel that is too large, (more than 3 millimeters in diameter) or you have large fish that are knocking the plants loose, the only trick is to keep plants down long enough to get their roots started. Once they are rooted, you should have no trouble at all.
My favorite method is to place no more than three stems at a time in the gravel, and then put a couple of small stones around the base, right up against the stems of the plants. This is usually sufficient to keep the plants in place, and within a week or so the roots should have grown enough that the stones can be removed.
Another method that works well for some plants is to just leave them floating until they develop some roots. The problem with this method is that the stems usually become curled when left floating on the surface, and it takes a few days for them to straighten out again once they are planted.
If all else fails, place the stem horizontally on top of the substrate and put a couple of stones on top of it near the cut end. Before long, the plant will root itself and the stones can be removed. In fact, you will probably find that the plant has begun to root at several nodes and is sending up new leaf shoots from these nodes as well. This last method can be used for cultivating many of the stem plants more quickly as well.
The Right Light
Q. I have a 75-gallon planted tank and I have a question about the lighting for my plants. One dealer told me that I should use a 50/50 tube along with a "blue" light. Then another dealer told me that the 50/50 and blue light were not designed for freshwater plants and he recommended that I use Penn-Plex Ultra Trilux or a similar type of tube. My question is which one would give me better plant growth? Is there any difference between the tubes? I'm only 15 and experimenting with them is much too costly. Thanks for your help.
A. Another young person learning to manage planted tanks early! Congratulations! Don't worry, particularly with a 4-foot tank. It is entirely possible to have quite good lighting for plants even on a shoestring budget.
As long as you have an adequate amount of light over your tank, the spectrum of those tubes is less important. Your second dealer, however, is correct that 50/50 and actinic (blue) lights are designed for marine tanks, and are not the best choice for a planted tank, either in terms of spectrum or cost.
Penn-Plax Ultra Trilux is an excellent tube, but like most tubes marketed to hobbyists, is on the expensive side. If you have a hood that will not allow you to add more tubes to the top of the tank, spending extra for high-end tubes like this may be worthwhile. If you are on a budget, however, you can obtain excellent growth using inexpensive standard 4-foot shop lights over your tank with "daylight" or "wide spectrum" tubes from your local home improvement store.
A 75-gallon tank with two shop lights (four tubes) will give you enough light to grow many hardy aquarium plants. If you can add a third shop light (six tubes) and are also using supplemental carbon dioxide, you can grow almost anything!