Fish Species at FishChannel.com

Undergravel Aquarium Filters

Are undergravel filters an outdated" piece of equipment for a freshwater aquarium?

By Jeremy Gosnell |

Printer Friendly

FishChannel.com Online Exclusive
Q. My local fish store (LFS) recommends using an undergravel filter in a freshwater aquarium. When I go to an online forum almost everyone tells me not to use one of these units. Should I use an undergravel filter like my LFS recommends or are they, as one forum user put it: “outdated.”
Sherry Turner
Virginia

A. Undergravel filters were once a great piece of aquarium equipment that many fishkeepers used in their aquariums. In fact, it wasn’t that long ago that undegravel filters were standard in most any aquarium (marine or freshwater). I can remember some of my first freshwater aquariums that used undergravel filters with powerheads to promote good aquarium water quality. These plastic-bottomed units with two plastic tube risers are inexpensive and easy to use, likely one reason they became so popular. The undergravel filter argument is popular on Internet forums because there seems to be a core of aquarists that are still proponents of using them and many new aquarists that are totally against the idea.

Today, using an undergravel filter as your only means of filtration seems like a bad idea. With the technological advances in power filtration it seems out of place to solely rely on an undergravel filter. The theory behind undergravel filters is sound and simple. Undergravel filters employ your aquarium’s gravel as their filter media along with uneaten fish food and fish waste. They provide oxygen to the bacteria living within the gravel via a powerhead or airstone mounted at the top of the supplied plastic tubes. This encourages the bacterial breakdown of wastes.

While I can’t recommend using an undergravel filter as the only filtration for any aquarium, I will say that it is a tried and true method of bacterial filtration. It provides bacteria with the necessary elements it needs to proliferate and thrive. When used in conjunction with power filtration, an undergravel filter could be a decent aquarium keeping tool.

These units do require regular maintenance. One important thing to consider is gravel vacuuming. This process, done with a siphon, will remove excess waste particles from your gravel, freeing up room for oxygenation. This will prevent anaerobiosis, or the creation of areas in the gravel bed where bacteria are not efficiently working to break down wastes. You must be careful not to over vacuum your aquarium gravel and therefore remove so many microbes from the system that it enters biological shock. One recommendation is cleaning only 50 percent of your aquarium’s gravel per cleaning. Using this method you can rotate areas cleaned and not fear that you have removed too much beneficial bacteria from your aquarium.

One instance where an undergravel filter has no place is in either a reef aquarium or freshwater planted aquarium. In either instance the undergravel filter is a hindrance and does not combine well with the other items needed to make those aquariums flourish.

Undergravel filters appear to be little more than plastic plates and tubes and are not nearly as interesting as more modern forms of filtration. The truth is the undergravel filter is a proven piece of aquarium equipment that is inexpensive and easy to implement. Many traditional aquarists who keep freshwater aquariums still use undergravel filters with good success.

To help settle the debate you have experienced online, I’ll say this: Neither the LFS you visited nor the aquarium forum users you spoke with are right or wrong. The undergravel filter can be an effective piece of aquarium equipment. Anything that works efficiently, is inexpensive, and easy to use, is never really “outdated.”

Printer Friendly

 Give us your opinion on
Undergravel Aquarium Filters

Submit a Comment   Join Club
Earn 1,000 points! What's this?
Reader Comments

Deborah    Tucson, AZ

9/19/2013 9:19:42

Article helped me decide if using underground was the best choice in setting up a planted fresh water tank.

Daniel    St. Petersburg, FL

8/12/2013 3:55:35 PM

I have always used an undergravel filter and my water is sparkling crystal clear. Guests always remark how beautiful my tank is (it is in the entryway) it must be a lot of work to keep it that way. I tell them NO it is no work at all, all I do is add water that evaporates, nothing else. I have an old Metaframe 55 gallon tank with a slate bottom I've owned for 40+years now. The last time I tore it down was when I installed Laminate Flooring over 12 years ago. Under Gravel is THE ONLY way to go for truly maintenance free aquariums.

David    International

4/9/2013 5:46:03

I think a reef aquarium could use a reverse flow undergravel filter under maybe just a quarter of the substrate...............the rest of the area could be a deep sand bed for denitrification. I think it would be fine if the powerhead intake had a sponge filter to remove particulate matter. For those wanting low tech set-ups which are not overcrowded, and which use live rock too.

Chey    Easton, PA

2/22/2013 7:59:40

When people come into my store and ask about the UGFs we still sell, mostly older customers who only had that type of filtration when they had fish as young adults, I tell them that it's more convenient to use a simple hang-on-back filter, but the UGF can also be used if you're willing to give it the maintenance it needs.

View Current Comments


Top Products

ADS BY GOOGLE